County Commissioner Criticizes Maryland Study

Carroll County commissioner says the State of Maryland is “cooking the books” in a study of the contribution of septic systems to pollution of the Chesapeake Bay. In a letter to the Baltimore Sun, Richard Rothschild disputed a claim that septic systems release ten times more nitrogen than urban wastewater treatment plants.

“To reach this number, they include estimates of lawn fertilizer per household and compare old septic technology to the most advanced treatment plants,” he wrote. “When adjusted for these factors, septics and sewers are virtually identical.”

He goes on to say the state inflated how much nitrogen going into the bay comes from Maryland, claiming that the report attributes to Maryland releases from New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Virginia, West Virginia and Washington, D.C. “Using their inflated measures, septics still only contribute a modest 4 percent of the total,” he said. “Yet they argue in the future, septics will contribute 76 percent of all new nitrogen.”

Meanwhile, a legislative task force has proposed tripling Maryland’s flush tax to speed upgrades of treatment plants and septic systems and control of stormwater. The $2.50 monthly fee is included on bills for those on sewer systems. Homes on septic tanks are charged the fee on their property tax bills. The proposed increase would double the fee at first, and increase it to $7.50 a month by 2015.

Meanwhile, an audit of septic system upgrade contracts has been sent to the Criminal Division of the attorney general’s office. Changes have since been made in the program, designed to upgrade septic systems to prevent problems found by the audit.

Through November 2011, the report says, more than 3,000 systems had been improved. The audit revealed that a former state employee received a consulting contract from the program, in apparent violation of state law. There are also questions about a few septic system installers who charged much more than others.

 

Florida

Florida commissioner of agriculture Adam Putnam, attorney general Pam Bondi, and numerous industry representatives filed opposition to U.S. EPA-mandated water pollution standards for the state.

Arguing that federal intervention is unnecessary, they asked the court to invalidate the January 2009 EPA numeric nutrient criteria standards that opponents state would be nearly impossible to meet and extremely costly.

The filing argues that the agency failed to provide a record to support its 2009 decision and exaggerated the impact and threat of nutrients generally and the situation in Florida specifically. The EPA will establish final standards by Aug. 15 unless the state Department of Environmental Protection develops its own rules, which the federal agency must approve.

 

Indiana

A petition drive by the citizens group Indiana Freedoms aims to persuade the state legislature to change the law requiring homeowners with onsite systems to connect to a sewer if their property is within 300 feet of the pipe. The group contends that forcing property owners with working septic systems to tie into sewers violates their rights.

State Senator Jean Leising introduced a bill that would have required sewer boards that are now appointed to be elected, and would have prohibited sewer districts from forcing property owners with functioning septic systems to connect to sewers. The bill never made it out of committee. Leising said she may submit another bill that would require sewer boards to be elected. The state has some 1 million onsite systems with 25 to 30 percent estimated to be in failure.

 

New Hampshire

State Rep. Adam Schroadter submitted legislation that would add a tax to sewer bills and a separate annual tax of $25 per toilet for onsite system owners. The revenue would go to a state fund for upgrading wastewater treatment plants to reduce nitrogen reaching Great Bay and possibly lead to expanded sewer service.

 

Washington

Clark County Commissioners, serving as the Board of Health, approved an ordinance that replaces a 6-cent-per-gallon sewage tipping fee with $16.50 added to the property taxes of 34,000 onsite system owners. The fee would fund a county operations and maintenance program. Depending on the type of system, state law requires inspections every one, two, or three years, and tanks pumped every three to five years.

 

Alaska

The U.S. Senate passed an appropriations bill that included $23 million for building onsite systems, piped systems, and holding tanks in rural Alaska native villages.

 

California

State officials spent months traveling the Golden State explaining new septic system rules that are long overdue. The reworked proposal puts more power in the hands of local water quality boards and depends less on statewide standards, required system testing, and other steps opponents said were not flexible enough. Public hearings are expected this spring. A California Water Board fact sheet states that 95 percent of septic system owners will not be affected by the changes – only those with failed systems or who live near a polluted stream, river or lake. The board is modifying the draft regulations, which were to be released in March. After a public comment period, final adoption was expected by June 2012.

 

Iowa

A high school student is now responsible for solving the problem of septic systems that don’t meet state standards. Jeremy Minnier, 18, was elected mayor of Aredale in November. Along with fixing the septic tank situation, he’d like to get roads in better shape and improve the look of the downtown.

 

Missouri

State officials say they will likely forgive fines for a bar owner who has failed to renew his septic system permit or file reports since as far back as 2004 – if the owner comes into compliance with state law. If not, the bar owner faces fines of up to $10,000 a day for each violation.



Discussion

Comments on this site are submitted by users and are not endorsed by nor do they reflect the views or opinions of COLE Publishing, Inc. Comments are moderated before being posted.